Guest Thinkers — August 24, 2009

Does punishment create a better society?

The following case I only mention because it is in the media daily.

A weekly newsletter featuring the biggest ideas from the smartest people

With the release of Lockerbie bomber A.M.al Megrahi a miscarriage of justice, perpetrated by the so-called international community, has been reversed. So at least a lot of people think, except people in the US it seems.

What would society “gain” from keeping this individual in prison? After all the whole case against him was very weak and circumstantial.

And why is it that churchgoers always have such strong urges for punishment?

Is punishment nothing but revenge, perhaps?

A weekly newsletter featuring the biggest ideas from the smartest people

Thinking

Instead of the death penalty, let’s put dangerous criminals in a coma

Prison is an unreliable method of punishment. Let’s do better.

The Present

We can halve most forms of violence by 2030. Here’s how.

A second step is to determine where violence concentrates and who is most at risk.

Politics & Current Affairs

Does the desire to punish have any place in modern justice?

Punishment has been a human universal, because it has been in our evolutionary interests. But those evolutionary impulses are crude guides to how we should deal with offenders in contemporary society.

Hope & Optimism

The Science, Philosophy, and Psychology of the Mind

Sponsored by the Hope & Optimism Initiative

The Charge of the Heavy Brigade; or, Totalitarianism Is Thriving and It Is Our Fault

The modern dictator needs only to become a client-state to Russia or China (or to be Russia or China), and there is nothing he can’t get away with. We members of open societies have the power to change that. All we need is the resolve.

Up Next

Politics & Current Affairs

Omnicharity

Omnicharity (n) — A group of cooperating charities working under one name, to benefit one or more causes.