Skip to content
Starts With A Bang —

Messier Monday: Messier’s Last Original Open Cluster, M93

Sign up for the Starts With a Bang newsletter
Travel the universe with Dr. Ethan Siegel as he answers the biggest questions of all

How the last open cluster ever discovered by Messier himself still holds some amazing secrets and wonder more than 200 years after its discovery.

“The journey is difficult, immense. We will travel as far as we can, but we cannot in one lifetime see all that we would like to see or to learn all that we hunger to know.” -Loren Eiseley

Welcome back to another Messier Monday here on Starts With A Bang! Since Galileo first turned a telescope upwards towards the heavens more than 400 years ago, we’ve recognized that there’s an entire Universe out there to explore beyond what’s visible to our naked eye. By the late 18th Century, Charles Messier set out to catalogue all the deep-sky objects — the extended, permanent fixtures in the night sky — visible with the equipment of his time. The idea was that comet-hunters would be able to reference his catalogue to prevent mistaking a permanent object for a transient comet, but what we wound up with was so much better.

Image credit: Tenho Tuomi of Tuomi Observatory, via http://www.lex.sk.ca/astro/.

What he instead compiled, with the help of his assistant, Pierre Méchain, was a catalogue of 110 deep-sky curiosities: the brightest and most interesting objects visible from most inhabited locations on Earth. (With some apologies to southern hemisphere dwellers.) Each Monday, we take an in-depth look at one of these, and today’s object is a good one even when there’s a nearly full Moon polluting your winter skies: Messier 93, the last open star cluster discovered by Messier himself. Here’s how to find it.

Image credit: me, using the free software Stellarium, via http://stellarium.org/.

After sunset tonight, a nearly full Moon rides above the constellation Orion, which is trailed by the brightest star in the night sky, Sirius, towards the east. Rising a bit later in the evening, the stars Wezen and Adhara form a prominent pair beneath the dog star, and these three — Sirius, Wezen and Adhara — can help guide you to Messier 93. What’s maybe even more key, however, is to remember the imaginary line formed by Orion’s belt, which you can connect to Sirius, and continue extending it.

Image credit: me, using the free software Stellarium, via http://stellarium.org/.

Rather than curve that imaginary line towards Wezen, Adhara and the other naked-eye stars in that vicinity, allow that bright pair to push your Orion’s belt-to-Sirius line slightly away from it, towards instead the naked-eye stars ξ Puppis and the slightly brighter ρ Puppis a little farther along.

Because if you can train your binoculars or telescope on ξ Puppis, just a smidge over a degree north of that naked-eye star you’ll find the last open cluster ever discovered by Messier himself: Messier 93!

Image credit: me, using the free software Stellarium, via http://stellarium.org/.

Described lackadaisically by Messier as a:

Cluster of small stars, without nebulosity, between the Greater Dog and the prow of the ship,

upon its discovery in 1781, it was just two years later that Caroline Herschel began her own catalogue with this very object — becoming the first woman to use her own telescope to catalogue observations — and realized what was truly going on here.

Image credit: RoryG of Eastex Astronomy, via http://eastexastronomy.blogspot.com/2010/08/cluster-of-open-clusters.html.

This is not a cluster of very small stars, as Messier had recorded, but of stars that are very far away, at a distance of some 3,600 light-years. Based on the colors, brightnesses and abundance of blue giants in the cluster — including a number of B-class stars — we can tell that this cluster is only about 100 million years old, or just 2% the age of the Solar System.

Image credit: © 2006 — 2012 by Siegfried Kohlert, via http://www.astroimages.de/en/gallery/M93.html.

But the next stars to die in this cluster won’t be the blue giants, they’ll be the red giants which have already run out of hydrogen fuel in their core. A number of such stars can be found with just a cursory glance at this cluster, but are really highlighted in an infrared view, such as the one provided by the Two-micron All-Sky Survey, below. (The two brightest ones really stand out!)

Image credit: Two-micron All Sky Survey (2MASS), IPAC.

At a more refined level, there are at least 80 identified stars present in this cluster, which spans maybe 20 to 25 light-years in diameter, with it very likely that there are many hundreds present inside. As is often the case, it quickly becomes very difficult to tell which of the faintest stars are members of the cluster itself, and which are background stars of the galactic plane.

Image credit: Digitized Sky Survey (DSS), via Courtney Seligman at http://cseligman.com/text/atlas/ngc24.htm#2447.

This is a problem for the vast majority of open clusters, and for almost all the open clusters in Messier’s catalogue. The vast majority of star formation in our galaxy takes place along the spiral arms, which means that virtually all open star clusters — or places where star formation recently took place — will not only be found in the galactic plane, but at a particular distance based on their location relative to the galactic center and their age.

And Messier 93 is no exception!

Image credit: Messier 93 via NOAO / AURA / NSF.

Even though it’s never been viewed with the Hubble Space Telescope, it’s really remarkable what amazing astrophotos can be taken from the ground by a dedicated amateur these days. Take a look at the core region as imaged by Jim Misti with a 32″ (0.8 m) telescope!

Image credit: Jim Misti of Misti Mountain Observatory, via http://www.mistisoftware.com/astronomy/Clusters_m93.htm.

How many faint stars are in there, lost against the glare of the brightest stars of the cluster? Hundreds? Maybe even thousands? Remember that Sun-like stars are a thousand times dimmer than the brightest ones in this photo, and that the Sun is intrinsically brighter than 95 percent of stars! Ponder that, along with what else lies inside of this star cluster, as we bring today’s Messier Monday to a close.

Including today, we’ve looked at the following Messier objects:

Come back again next week, for a new deep-sky treat from the night sky, and an all-new Messier Monday!

Sign up for the Starts With a Bang newsletter
Travel the universe with Dr. Ethan Siegel as he answers the biggest questions of all
Related
Up Next